On the second full day of the Barack Obama administration, the Environmental Protection Agency has placed the brakes on two coal-fired power plant projects. The EPA “placed a hold on approval of Otter Tail Power’s proposed 500 MW Big Stone II coal-fired power plant in South Dakota.” The plant is sited at the Minnesota border to take advantage of South Dakota’s weaker environmental regulations. However, in a letter sent to the South Dakota Department of Environment and Natural Resources yesterday — the final day for review — the EPA said the state “didn’t meet requirements under the Clean Air Act in part of its proposed permit for the plant.”
In a joint statement, Clean Water Action and the Sierra Club said the decision “likely spells the end of Otter Tail Power’s Big Stone II coal plant”:
At a minimum, Otter Tail Power will have to go back to the drawing board and redesign the project to incorporate the best and maximum available control technology for pollution like soot and smog. Sierra Club and Clean Water Action will be pushing for EPA to set limits also for carbon dioxide, the main contributor to global warming.
The EPA’s Environmental Appeals Board yesterday stayed another coal plant, the 1,500-megawatt Desert Rock Energy Station in Navajo Nation land in New Mexico. In its decision, the board agreed to “review an air permit the EPA approved in July” for the plant.
However, because of a last minute order by outgoing EPA Administrator Stephen Johnson, the EPA is currently enjoined from considering carbon dioxide pollution in coal plant permits. Johnson’s memorandum reversed to a November decision by the Appeals Board to block a coal plant for not considering global warming pollution.
The fate of these plants — and our climate — now rests in the hands of President Obama and his just-confirmed EPA Administrator, Lisa Jackson. If they choose to do so, they can make the official finding that carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases endanger our health and welfare — a finding blocked for years by George W. Bush.


Ford has a plug-in hybrid Escape SUV with a 40 mile all-electric range and a 180,000 mile battery life, but it apparently can’t do highway speeds without burning gas. The $22,000 BYD Auto DualMode has a new lithium-ferrous battery technology, and I can’t remember what its expected life is, but it doesn’t need to burn gas to go fast. Sheesh.
January 23rd, 2009 at 10:31 pmPerhaps this means that there is hope that the Wise County coal plant being pushed by Dominion Resources in Virginia will also come under fresh scrutiny!
January 26th, 2009 at 10:59 pmBlocking coal fired plants because some of you think they are dangerous to the environment should consider how you will light your homes, heat your electric blankets and cook your meals in the future.
January 27th, 2009 at 1:11 amCoal provides 60+% of the electric energy in this country. What do you think will take its place? Oil,solar,wind energy, ethanol? If you think that is the answer I would encourage you to rapidly develop another life style. You are going to need it.
grassfarmer, we don’t “think” coal plants are dangerous, we KNOW they are. Coal is the dirtiest fossil fuel we use and they most damaging to the environment except for the tar sands. Coal plants are dead, their won’t be anymore. So yeah, if you think that will change your lifestyle better get used to the idea, or back President Obama’s ideas to move forward on renewable fuels like wind and solar. That’s what will power us in the future. Easily. Nobody needs coal but the coal CEOs.
January 29th, 2009 at 11:47 am