The Wonk Room

Republicans Fear Too Many Children Will Be Crowded Into SCHIP

schipchild.jpgToday, during a Senate Finance Committee hearing about SCHIP expansion, Sen. Jon Kyl (R-TX), like his Republican colleagues in the House, argued that expanding SCHIP would force millions of children with private coverage into a public program.

During last year’s SCHIP debate, Republicans similarly used this “crowd out” argument — the idea that expanding a public program would motivate families of children who currently have private coverage to voluntarily “drop that coverage for their children and enroll the children in SCHIP or Medicaid instead” — to keep from expanding the program.

Kyl cited the Congressional Budget Office’s (CBO) estimate that 2.2 to 2.4 million children who would gain SCHIP or Medicaid coverage would have otherwise had private coverage. But as the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities explains, “crowd-out is not the same as voluntarily dropping private health insurance for public program coverage”:

In other words, a large share of the SCHIP “crowd-out,” as estimated by CBO, involves children who are uninsured now but who would obtain private coverage at some later point if SCHIP (or Medicaid) coverage were not available to them. These are not children who had private insurance that their families voluntarily dropped for public program coverage.

In fact, as the center points out, “only a small share of children had private health insurance before enrolling in SCHIP or Medicaid.” An Urban Institute study that examined how 18 states are addressing crowd out concluded, “among the 18 study states, SCHIP and Medicaid officials, as well as other key informants, consistently reported little to no concern over crowd out; many believed it was a non-issue.”

Moreover, “the Congressionally-mandated 10-state evaluation of SCHIP found that while 28 percent of newly enrolled children had private coverage before joining SCHIP, half of them — or 14 percent —lost their private insurance for involuntary reasons before enrolling in SCHIP, such as when parents lost their jobs or became divorced or employers stopped offering health insurance for dependents.”

Indeed, the harsh economic climate has certainly made insurance less affordable and has led many Americans to lose their employer-sponsored coverage. As Sen. Olympia Snowe (R-ME) pointed out during the hearing, “it’s the cost of private insurance that excludes them from having coverage. More and more Americans are losing coverage becay they can’t afford it. Small businesses can’t afford to provide it.”

Update The Senate Finance Committee voted 12 to 7 to increase spending on SCHIP by $31.5 billion. The committee also passed an amendment, introduced by Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-WV), extending coverage to legal immigrants.





One Response to “Republicans Fear Too Many Children Will Be Crowded Into SCHIP”

  1. Ehlert Says:

    Paint shop pro 7 picture tubes
    Petchara video
    Pussy tube
    Screaming orgasm videos
    Nicole sheridan videos
    Roles oyster professional watch
    Plastic storage tubes
    Reb tube
    Reboot cartoon sound clips
    Prince albert piercing video
    Preakness video
    Rawalpindi net hot videos
    Nose clips
    Old omega watch
    Piaget possession watch
    Phase converter plans
    Nudists videos
    Ps3 porn videos
    Parmigiani kapla watch
    Pam and tommy sex video
    Pcr tube
    Original sin sex scene clip
    Rough sex video clips
    Rado watch
    Panerai arktos watch
    Ogenki clinic clips
    Prarie dog videos
    Saddam hussein execution video
    Popping her cherry video
    Rolex submariner watch
    Naughty bloopers videosSarah young tube
    Robin williams golf video
    Revenge girlfriend videos
    Next door nikki video
    Puma video to psp converter v2.2
    Selina spice videos
    Nickelback savin me video
    Santaria sublime video
    Roger dubuis sports activity watch
    Ron jeremy free porn videos
    Sadam hussein online video hanging
    Sara jean underwood video
    Penelope cruz video
    Sadam hanged video
    Productions wedding video
    Revenge ex girl video
    Rs485 with current loop converter
    Realdoll videos
    Peg tube removal
    Ptfe tube
    Neural tube defect
    Rgb to hdmi converter
    Roger dubuis hommage watch
    Nos tubes
    Phd program education videos
    Problems with small ureter tubes
    Nina hartley free video
    Rimming videos
    Replica watch reviews
    Ronaldinho skill video
    Nicole sheridan clips
    Nude underwater video
    Raymond mens watch
    Sapphire video card
    Realistic sex videos
    Sex clip samples
    Positives of video games
    Princess diana funeral video
    Nikki benz videos
    Puma watch
    Saddam\’s execution video
    Porn tube free
    Queefing video
    Rhino choke tubes
    Replica rolex watch
    Pooping clips
    Pre cum clips
    Pens with spring clip
    Remington gun parts clips 581 541
    Nephilim rising video download jeff mason
    Nike clear presto women watch
    Pilates exercise video
    Orca clip art
    Print watch crack
    Psp tubes victorian rooms
    Seduction heartbeat music video
    Scandelous home sex videos
    Promotional video production
    Pierre kunz g 403 watch
    Presley maddox video clip
    Notebook video cards
    Richard speck prison video
    Plastic bag breathplay videos
    Personal clips
    Science think tube
    Sapphic erotica sample video
    Qmail server video torrents
    Oliver klozov michelle jenny video
    Pornstar tube



Jump to Top

About Wonk Room | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2008 Center for American Progress Action Fund
image Register imageimageRSSimageimage imageimage
image
Latest Posts

Advertisement

Issues

Alerts

image
Sign up for Wonk Room Alerts



image
Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
imageTopic Cloud


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll


imageAbout Wonk RoomimageimageContact UsimageimageDonateimage